We really liked and agreed with the concepts in the book, and had lengthy discussions about how rewards can end up "punishing" children because in the end the child will focus on the reward instead of learning whatever it is you want them to learn. Now, at this time in our lives we had one young toddler and were idealistic about our parenting styles and thought that we would never stoop to bribery and other such practices...Fast forward four years. As I've mentioned in a previous post, we have recently been potty training our three-year-old. As a reward, we have let him choose a little Hershey's kiss (or similar small chocolate or prize) after he goes to the bathroom. This has worked out great to be honest, and we are about to phase this out as it really isn't needed anymore. Burke has felt a little left out of these "rewards" and doesn't understand why he doesn't get a chocolate for going to the bathroom (the boy gets plenty of treats so don't think that he is completely neglected). I've explained to Burke that Hewitt is rewarded because he is doing something that is challenging for him. This gave me an idea for Burke: to reward him for reading chapter books. Burke is a really great reader but has been intimidated by the size of chapter books. Although we would love for him to discover the joy of reading silently without any other reward besides the feeling of accomplishment and enjoying the story, we asked him to suggest a reward for completing chapter books that he reads on his own. He came up with the following:
Suggestion #1: Buy him his own mansion and limousine. (Denied.)
Suggestion #2: Let him live in Disneyland. (Denied.)
Suggestion #3: Decorate our house on the outside to look like a real haunted house. (Denied.)
Suggestion #4: Give him a "free dollar" for each chapter book read. Agreed.
Are we bad parents because we bribe and reward our children from time to time? I sure hope not...and I have a feeling we aren't alone.
Suggestion #2: Let him live in Disneyland. (Denied.)
Suggestion #3: Decorate our house on the outside to look like a real haunted house. (Denied.)
Suggestion #4: Give him a "free dollar" for each chapter book read. Agreed.
Are we bad parents because we bribe and reward our children from time to time? I sure hope not...and I have a feeling we aren't alone.
